We use essential cookies

Please Accept our Privacy Policy

Insurance Sales Producer (In-Office, Paid Training and Licensing)

Fallon Insurance Agency

Oshkosh, WI 54901 • $80,000 to $156,000 / yr • 10/31/2026

Job Description

Job Description

Are you competitive? Do you like talking to people and winning?

If so, keep reading.

My name is Leland Fallon. I own Fallon Insurance Agency, a AAA agency in Oshkosh, and I’m hiring a Sales Producer to work in our office.

Most families are paying too much for insurance or have coverage that wouldn’t hold up if something went wrong. Your job is to fix that. You’ll talk with people all day, find out what they need, and help them protect their home, their cars, and their family with AAA. When you do that well, you earn well.

A little background on us. Before opening with AAA, I built an insurance book of about $1.6 million in around 18 months. Our agency earned the Blue Vase award, made Toppers Club, and finished #1 in our district. Now we sell for AAA, a name people already know and trust. That makes a big difference when you pick up the phone.

Here’s what we believe in:

People. We don’t need you to have insurance experience. Some of our best people came from restaurants, retail, and other sales jobs. If you’re coachable, competitive, and you show up every day, we can teach you the rest.

Systems. You won’t be figuring this out alone. We have a proven sales script, a clear process for every call, and daily coaching. You’ll know exactly what to do and what good looks like.

Growth. Zig Ziglar said you can have everything in life you want if you will just help enough other people get what they want. That’s how sales works here. Help enough families, and your income follows.

Pay. $2,500 plus a commission ladder that grows as your production grows. The more you write, the higher your percentage, and it pays back to your first dollar once you move up a level. After 90 days, the agency pays half of your employee premium for medical, dental, or vision. You also earn paid time off, and you’re eligible for our 401(k) after one year.

Questions you might have:

Do I need insurance experience?

No. We’ll train you from day one.

Do I need a license?

Not to apply. If you aren’t licensed yet, we’ll pay you while you study and help you pass the state exam. Most people finish in about 30 days. If you’re already licensed, even better. You’ll be selling sooner.

Do I have to find my own leads?

No. We provide the leads and live transfers. You make the calls and close the sales.

What are the hours?

Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Your weekends are yours.

Is this remote?

No. This is an in-office job at our agency on Witzel Avenue in Oshkosh.

What’s the team like?

Competitive, but we’re on the same side. We push each other, we celebrate big days, and we help each other through slow ones.

Responsibilities
  • A typical day looks like this:
  • Start the morning with our team huddle.
  • Make outbound calls and take live transfers throughout the day.
  • Quote home, auto, and life insurance, with a focus on home and auto bundles.
  • Close and bind policies on the first call whenever you can.
  • Help clients see the value of AAA membership and the AAA credit card, with monthly goals for both.
  • Follow up with every quote until you get a clear yes or no.
  • Keep clean notes in our CRM so every client gets a great experience.
  • Hit your monthly production goals and keep improving with weekly coaching.
Requirements
  1. You’re competitive and you like to win.
  2. You’re comfortable on the phone all day.
  3. You take coaching well and act on it quickly.
  4. You show up on time, every day.
  5. You can handle hearing no and still make the next call with a smile.
  6. You’re comfortable on a computer and can learn new software.
  7. You’re willing to get your Wisconsin Property and Casualty and Life licenses within 30 days of hire, plus any other state licenses we need. We’ll support you the whole way.
  8. You’re authorized to work in the United States.

If you’re ready to build a career where your effort decides your income, apply today. We’d like to meet you.

Benefits
  • Paid Time Off (PTO)
  • Hands on Training
  • Mon-Fri Schedule
  • Career Growth Opportunities
  • Health Insurance
  • Dental Insurance
  • Vision Insurance