We use essential cookies

Please Accept our Privacy Policy

Customer Service Insurance Agent

Milestone Insurance Agency Inc

York, PA • $45,000 to $60,000 / yr • 11/17/2026

Job Description

Job Description

$45,000–$60,000 base salary plus commission
York, PA | Full-time | December 2026 start

Milestone Insurance Agency is growing and adding a Customer Service Representative to our three-person team in York. You’ll help clients with their auto, home and other personal insurance, from answering day-to-day questions to reviewing coverage and writing new policies.

Pay and Benefits

39-hour workweek with a paid 30-minute lunch. Monday–Thursday, 9 a.m.–5 p.m. Friday, 9 a.m.–4 p.m. In office for the first 90 days, with the option to work remotely two days per week after that.

Base salary plus commission on business you write. Earn 7% of written premium on new personal and commercial P&C policies and 80% of the agency’s commission on life insurance you write. Additional performance bonuses are available.

Three weeks of paid time off (120 hours) annually after 90 days, prorated in your first year. SIMPLE IRA with a 3% employer match once eligible.

What You’ll Do

Help clients with policy changes, billing, renewals and claims questions. Process endorsements and issue insurance ID cards.

Review accounts at renewal, identify coverage gaps or potential savings, and explain available options to clients.

Identify new personal lines business and cross-selling opportunities. Once licensed and appointed, quote and write policies that meet clients’ needs.

Work with carriers to resolve policy and coverage questions. Keep client records current in EZLynx and attend occasional client meetings, inspections or agency events. Business mileage is reimbursed.

Who Would Thrive Here

Personal lines insurance service or sales experience is preferred. If you’re new to insurance, we welcome experience helping the public in roles such as banking, healthcare front desks, retail or office support.

You listen, explain next steps clearly and stay calm when a customer is frustrated.

You pick up new software quickly and keep accurate records while juggling requests.

You take ownership of requests, follow through and work toward clear goals.

Licensing and Other Requirements

Paid path to a Pennsylvania P&C license. An active license is preferred. If you’re unlicensed, aim to take the exam in your third week. You’ll need to pass and submit your license application within 60 days of starting. Milestone pays for study materials, your first exam and your initial license fee, and provides paid study and exam time.

Ability to obtain required carrier appointments, including Erie. A valid driver’s license and auto insurance are needed for occasional business travel.

A life insurance license is a plus and earns a $500 signing bonus if held at hire. With prior approval, we cover licensing costs if you earn it within your first six months.

\nCompany Description

Milestone Insurance Agency, Inc. is a growing independent insurance agency based in York, Pennsylvania. Since 2020, we’ve helped individuals, families, and businesses with auto, home, business, and life insurance. We work with multiple insurance carriers, which lets us compare options and help clients make informed decisions about their coverage.

Our team helps clients throughout the life of their policies, from answering billing questions and updating coverage to reviewing renewals and helping them understand the next steps after a claim. We explain insurance in plain language, pay attention to the details, and follow through when a client needs help.

As our agency grows, we’re adding to our York team. We value insurance experience and welcome people who’ve built strong customer service skills in other fields. If you’re new to insurance, we provide paid study and exam time and cover the study materials, first exam, and initial license fee for your Pennsylvania Property & Casualty license.

Company Description

Milestone Insurance Agency, Inc. is a growing independent insurance agency based in York, Pennsylvania. Since 2020, we’ve helped individuals, families, and businesses with auto, home, business, and life insurance. We work with multiple insurance carriers, which lets us compare options and help clients make informed decisions about their coverage.\n\nOur team helps clients throughout the life of their policies, from answering billing questions and updating coverage to reviewing renewals and helping them understand the next steps after a claim. We explain insurance in plain language, pay attention to the details, and follow through when a client needs help.\n\nAs our agency grows, we’re adding to our York team. We value insurance experience and welcome people who’ve built strong customer service skills in other fields. If you’re new to insurance, we provide paid study and exam time and cover the study materials, first exam, and initial license fee for your Pennsylvania Property & Casualty license.